A student from Bayi Vocational School in Yushu, Qinghai
province, works on a painting. Experts and officials are encouraging the
development of modern vocational education to ease the imbalance between labor
supply and the huge demand for technical talent. Zhang Hongxiang / Xinhua
How can China launch a manned spaceship but can't produce high-quality
kitchen knives?
The question was raised by members of the Chinese People's Political
Consultative Conference earlier this year and triggered a heated debate in
China's education system, where experts and officials urged the development of
modern vocational education to ease the imbalance between the labor supply and
the huge market demand for technical talents.
"There is an urgent need to reform our current education system, which has
been struggling to provide high-quality talents with skills and knowledge that
meet the demand at the production frontline," Lu Xin, China's deputy minister of
education, said at the recent China Development Forum 2014.
"The key for the reform is to push the development of modern vocational
education, which will help ease the grim employment situation," Yin Jie, a CPPCC
member and deputy director of the Shanghai Education Committee, said.
"Despite technical innovation, the lack of vocational skills for front-line
workers has hampered the development of technologies and the upgrade of
traditional manufacturing," said Yin.
Shen Qifang, a National People's Congress deputy and the vice-principal of
Huzhou Vocational and Technical College, urged a more practical approach that
adapts school courses to industrial requirements.
"For quite a long period, what the students learned at vocational schools had
little to do with what the job required, and that reflects the split between
education and industry in China," Shen said during a group interview on March
11.
Citing advanced vocational training methods in Germany and Australia, Shen
suggested that more foreign experience and a new curriculum should be introduced
to help develop vocational education as Premier Li Keqiang called for in the
government work report.
Taking Germany as an example, Shen said its dual system, in which teaching
content and methods are jointly determined by industries and training schools to
reflect current industrial practice, attracts some 60 percent of school-leavers
annually.
It has been a major factor behind the country's world-renowned manufacturing
industry, according to WorldSkills International, a nonprofit association that
promotes vocational training worldwide.
Inspired by foreign expertise, Shen said more international exchanges
involving students and teachers have taken place in recent years, and overseas
experience has started to pay off.
Dai Yuwei, president of Tianjin Light Industry Vocational Technical College,
said a faculty training trip to Australia helped optimize his college's
approach.
"We were highly impressed by their advanced curriculum and are going to
introduce it to our accounting program," said Dai, who has been sending his
faculty members to Australia since 2011.
The college is also in negotiation with technical and continuing education
institutes in Australia to invite teachers to lecture, Dai said.
However, the foreign model won't seamlessly fit in with the Chinese market,
experts said.
Companies in other countries usually conduct vocational training by signing
employees first and then sending them to study at cooperative training schools
funded by the government, but this scenario won't happen in China, Yin said.
"Chinese companies are not facing a worker shortage, so they don't bother to
invest in vocational training," Yin said.
Shen agreed, calling for more policy support such as lower taxes and
subsidies to encourage more enterprises to cooperate with vocational
institutes.
"Otherwise, companies will just hire regular workers and replace them with
other workers after finding they are incapable of working effectively at the
assembly line," Shen said.
Meanwhile, multichannel management has emerged as another headache because
students have to take extra tests to apply for skill certificates issued by the
Ministry of Civil Affairs after graduating from vocational schools regulated by
the Ministry of Education.
With a lack of cross-ministry cooperation, the training students receive in
schools sometimes varies a lot and has led to instances of exam cheating or
false certificates.
He Libo, a graduate from Chaoyue Vocational School in Changzhi, Shanxi
province, said some of his classmates even tried to buy fake certificates before
applying for jobs.
Yang Genlai, deputy director of the Ministry of Civil Affairs' vocational
skill assessment and guidance center, said a national system in which unified
courses and training could be settled in line with the job description, and
certificate requirements, should be built as soon as possible.