配色: 字号:
对话教学_为思维而教
2012-04-27 | 阅:  转:  |  分享 
  
?4 ?3ù?aDVol14,No13

2008M6JournalOfEducationalStudiesJun12008


là°ù:2008201225

T?eo:
g?ó(1972)),o,qB,?|,?ê
=SvD?aD"p
Vù?
3,?1V
Y?ae ?ù?b

á[":''ó¤?ê
=SvD2008Ma?p
V
3?!á(I|:20080021)''ùb

??D:1
±?7?


g?ó

(华东师范大学教育学系,上海200062)

K1:
±?¥N′31?a¥·?,?? s
LC?b?7.d?D[=?1??,
^B?
±??D¥

ù?1b?÷?j
T1
±?2T¥
?DT1
±?V?¥
?¥uYb?D?
^B[1
± I7?D

¥
m
,?D?¥??
^μr4ùbμr4ù·ù5;5 ?=??
ü?4
Uá
ì?D
33?¥?+?¥?

??T,¨ ?w????D
3ísù5
H¥
± Ié?b]
H,μr4ù?·?
=?D
3¥ísé?k?
1

ù,1pD
3YVQ
±1-¥
Sís ?3
da£?|?1-¥
?
±
?Xb

1oM:?D ?
?;
±?;??D;μr4ù

?ms ?|:G421óDS
M
?:AócI|:167321298(2008)0320031205


ì¥?DB°[=?1??,]
H<?[
±

I1??¥
2{9B°? ''?9,?=??Da?


± I?D
???1?DdB8¥ ?
?b?Tá


ìê4
1
± I7?,ü? $¤1- ?n
?
q=

?¥
HW,8è=?S? I
k7yM?×1,?

7,?1

± I7?D,ü
HW¨=?
,á
ìü


?]á
ì?!
?¥''Sbá
ì????!


±????8"?!?
±??DD=??D??d

B?

Ba?a¥
P:1
±?7?


±?
^ü|??tuY 7 ?¥?,
^|¥?

e¥"?8C,×1?¤?
??
=Y1° $

¥?a,?
^
±?8
1×1?1
I
1×1?á
ì¥

?3?)′?b¥aQ
b
?[,??ˉ
?

y:A3ób
±?¥N′b

(B)
±?D
±?¥N′


ì
±?¥N′--μA15kb
I
1
^
±

?b/
±? 7
S?? í
 V¥?-
^ g¥
?,

?????¥
??,
kmùs? ?@??
,


j? ¥
Y
L,[Lùst£ ,V7???t
Y


L4N-W¥1"b0[1]3Q
8
±?ü?Qy ?£

¥$
,
Yt¥ V??
^??
?''
&¥?#,

7
^YV?T1£
üa£ aG ¥
e
Yt ?8

Cb0/B?μ
±?¥|,??| %?éù¥ I
nb
?

?Sμ"d¥!b
??
Pá
ì¥?? μ
''
±


?
n?1 $¥Z
T,[Lr?? ?¥"¥,?
a·

èá
ì???[r?C A ??
^ù¥"

¥b0[1]13| ?
3?D¥é
| %?
±?¥é


b
? X;
?#
±?¥T¨,/??|V
Y??
Y

t,?? ? AET1??¥ ??,?
?
e¨''

?2?,
?
? μ¥ ?3 ?????
e,
?μ¥

?? ?,?
??à,?
s?? AE¥·?,|
ì??

¥4Qai`?
^? e?
e
ì¥í±¥ ?
,|
ì

?R¥
¨V?? ?
b0[1]17% à8
?

±?¥N

′:/w
?$|
ì
j1
3?¥?v
Yt,
??|
?

°
?
H
? Y?31??
e
àμ°¤43?¥
Y
L,

??é2atZ?aD
3?¥
Y,o
^?£ ai

? ??????,?q
Y
^1¨?V
Y7¥?

T?¥b0[1]16|
ìXü?R?a,]y
í
^%M

¥$,?Tá
ì¥h7
àμtiOg??t

]¥y
í,
1??%M¥?
3|??
^
?"¥aB

e}?¥b/
±?''
^B?1 $1 ?3]y
í¥

V?b0[1]56
±?
^
P%M?1 V?¥y
í,
^ e?

%M¥y
íb

(=)?!
±?? ?:?a¥
P


±?¥N′??1?1?1C
L,/
±?31%

?7??¥?a¥·?,?? s
LC

?b0[1]17T

±?? ?¥
vN′ü?:/e5ü

V
±? s_7¤¥il,μ V?xíK?¥

32?aD2008M

?¨?
3?¥??`?
Yqb0[1]16???aE

9
^üD
3
±?? ?¥?!T1Dn?a¥B[
E

s×1¥?b/?a??ˉ?D
38<a
?3¥

ü,
???
PD
3á ???!
±?¥???,T1

r?
L=¥?e'' ??¥?1¥B?
m
b0[2]í

?,S?μB??4?,a13R/aa
?0?F?

w ?? ?,? 14Rb??/í?$0¥4??f

??
±??w ??4ú?a¥S
^K???1

o¥bíM ?
9???
??S¥/8`}D0ü
^B


ê
ê¨ ?D
3é?
±?? ??!¥ [?b?!


±?? ?
^?a
5×¥B"??,ê
?7 ?,XíE

íEb

=a?DC
,
j:
±??D¥ù?

??
=a1D
3o1:t [''=?,??

?|¤úsü
a
ü
eXüg?
?
M,:t
??

ü??àQ=?,ü?3?]? ?3b
e
ì??3

?-?
?μ=?¥?M W?,%31a1?!D


3¥
±?? ?
,=?÷F×1byN,D5??


=!]?ZD
3¥
±?? ?,?
e
ì¥?Dˉ[:

k(=?)1??,:k
T¥K??D?-¥ [


Ll?] a
], 1? V?b?
=1?¥
^=?

?r
q,D
3pa,i??
ìD
3
^????

ps?¥,o
^e?wD
3¥XE V?
^
I
1,

?aá
?
e??s?[??
HW,???
e
ì
3

???
?¥s?9?1?,?D"S?
^
± I?

àQ¤¥2
?,7
^4?
=a1??¥s?b


′x
àμ1??D
38"Xa8"yàQ1-¨b

?7,ù5
^D
3?T??,9?S??w ?,ü

i?"
e
ì?''
àS??Db??Dp¥1

?
L
^<?=?1?Z?¨?|a?? ?÷

×1,??aD
^B?V?b=?¥1?
P?


qE ?
???¤?]eb?7,?
qEùé
±?¥

$??,$???
±?
^ ?¥,$????V
U?


?? ?3,9V
Uz?¥hD,
PD?1B

 mμ
P7
ì?í?b??ˉ
?
a/?
=??^

ê4?<??
e
??¥2TMBá¥tin,

??ZE3?
D
3¥ ??¥3??bo?V o


=¥·?/,^<?
′¥?B",μ^F
2¥
a

? ?7Xb0[1]226?"¥?D?
D
3
±?¥q

?,D
3üè^·TD
B" F
± Ib/}:9?


μBt??,? ''d
^???D¥T¨,7??
^

"V
???DS¥?i?7Xb0[3]
±??D¥

ù??1.d?D¥y%b

?a.d?D¥p?
!:j
±?V?

¥
?D
±?2T¥
?


Ll
5×,×
j=?a[#
a?=?.
q¥?


qE¥?
?? 1? V?,?á
ì?¤?
± I??

??b4Q
^?1¥5?,BM4Q?
^??
!

¥
?ì? ?wb?á
ì?-%
,?1-¥?D

L
!??D?1
H,?DD¥ AEü?e
y7,

yNá
ìμA1ù.d?D¥?
!,? ??

é?
,
j,oμ?
ò÷,í?
±?¥?,???

!ù5?1¥?÷,? V???1¥?Mb

.d?D×
j?
M,
Lü
^×
jT1
±?2

T¥
?b7T1
±?2T¥
?DT1
±?V?

¥
?
^μuY¥bN,ˉ;SVúB
?
?b

T1
±?2T¥
?¥?
T?
^¨?¤?Q??


M,7
^¨ ?
a
üXüw ?¥2
?,?T1K

μr¥Z
T
a?Y|?M?2
?¥???b??
?

?¤2
?¥
±?V?¥
?μ''é¥uYb


±?V??,|
ìé???43,?????
?
"¥

ù5¥s?
^
I
1, V??V
Y?¥?,
ì


?μt
?",2
??
^B/0ü?¤?,31QV

h ? A A<V¥??,i_°B/[-¥
±?=?

2
?¥¤ μ
?Y,
^8"?
3?Y¥,?

"-4?2
?ü? ?
4N¥1",?ü
^
±?V

?¥
??
Tb¨[Vr
±?2T¥
??
Ti?

???á
ìP4?
ì¥f ?/ù?¤2
?¥

Z
Tb? ?¥
ì? μ? ?=?μ?''¥u

YbT1V?¥
?i?"
?
a
?S
^μ??1a

μ ?:?,
eD?° ?ü
e
?Y L¥£ Tb#,


e?"?
e
??|¥
m
??z1???| ?

¤¥2Tb|¤2
?-a,
e¨£ ?_2
?,

A2
?
^?_¤t?bü
??¨
±?V?

?,ü?%?7?^
q,
,
H
]a
''
±
?
n,%?¥

1??????£ ?L
!b

.d?D×
jT12T¥
?,eyü?a

1,
?¥"d¥V
?id?|
±?¥2T,
?
^?

Y|Si[??¥?
T4 ?,Dp¤???


T¥V?í1boμ?D
3¥D]??=?M?


H,
e
�???M???
?¥bü
?¥?

??]?E?+?e5S¥1???¥??a

F?a?sbyN,?ayT?¥
?¥y
í
^??

¥?
M,?
^D
3¥
??
±?8,a1D
3¥?

?¥T¨í1?1,¨?¥?
M¥
?}9
D


3=¥
±?¥
?,¨Y|¥
±?2T¥
?}

?3ù??D:1
±?7?33

9
D??|¥
±?V?¥
?b/?T? ?V

??C=?¥
??,
1
??L
^V??<F

¥,5T
B?
^?h¥ê,?±? ? 7


a?¥o?,é?<?o?,
±?ü?1
7|
Pn

?¥V?,y1
^??V??¤¥,y7??
^?

?¥T
,
e¥"¥?2T??
±?¥8,7

????T¥Bá?b
e
ì-
j
Q
8¥???
?

?¥`_
^18`??
?%μ¥b/8`μB

?é?w
?¥?
3
íé,iOμ
L?_¥=

??b0[3]69??¥=?
L=
^E|¤¥ò?2
?

F[i
ê4 ??¥,üE¥??T1D?¥

?,?]/üúb
?-B",ü2TbV?-


?0,
^ù¥??? ?¥b.d?D???BG L

Be¥:k??|1¥?|¥
?
T??¥?

??,D
3?
MoμB? ?3,D
31-¥
3?

¥
?
±???vJ??(¥
àμ?r¥
?,


P¤D
3
0? ?¥¨,é7
0DbB?|

1X¤
±?? ?oμ? 1-¥Cμ
£ü,é?


27?
á¥
±?byN,.d?D×
j=?¥p

-)ü?j
?¨?2T¥
??
T??¨

?V?¥
?¥ZEbT1V?¥
?DT12

T¥
?,á
ìA?Susb

.d?D
^?.
qY|¥43aw ?2T ó"

B¥,Vs<? ??
M¥ ?X,?÷??


a?1l
DY|?
M¥×1?, ??¥D

?? ? ??
Ma:t?
M,?
^?T? ?3?


M,?
Mü?
B?üh?¥μ?b1o
^8"

ü???
T¥DM1 ??¥??boμü?D

ATB?V?,"d¥ e??
±??·?
±?¥

??Hq,??.
q¥?
M?,¤ ??¥m)b


1aμr?:??D
3
±?

/
±?÷?P,
^B??4ùa?3sa

?ùa?
ü μ¥V?bYè
^?8=?é

?,
^=?¥,1ù1s¥b0?7,??¥4ù,?

?1
±??
3¥?byN[4ù1??¥?D

?°m?
2vé,B
^ú?? b?D
^

?¥
êì ??D?¥}DZE,B°
@.?°b
ê

ì ???? ?GPD?JDú:e1}V¥

GPE
ì
?é?¥?
M.?ZE,?f?D¥? V

??b
êì ???f,r?? ?¥V??,
^D

?1
&YV/D''ík0r?
? ?b
êì ??


a,?V
^1
??/D''ík074ù?úùà


b
êì ??¥ùsEaá?
?,
^1ù?"¥
±X

|ê:D
^?? ?¥?
=?D?-W¥

Y???¥b
êì ??7
S¥/?D0¥.d,

1ùC}¥D ?
?)))üD??1?Y¥


?V?)))¤[.?b}V
±Xü
^ˉ??

TG¥D ?
?bˉ4/T1Y¥D0?

B5bˉ¥D??
^?8Dìa¥?oT

¨,7O
^] Z8?a]
e|?a]1
&?¥

Y¥×???oT¨b''D
^?Y¥b?

T
?9üD?1YV?
Z 7
e¥ ?
?b


e¥}VT5
±?D?y6,/DT1Y0¥?5

S5?Xü?
üA
bù
???,???y(Y

¥?y)?=?¥?y(
±?¥?y)aKí?Zu
^

?
?¥?5-Bb?t
?5?
^/YD0 ?
?¥

8?b
ea1D
n5
^¨?y¥B?
?

?,???Z
n5VC1|=1"Y?¥
?V

?bKí?Zui?"8`¥?Z V??b8`¥

?Z V??| %??8`D?
=¥1"a]
e8

`¥1",
s
?fa¥??,
^1ù [=¥|=

1"
?¥?¥bD
^1ùy ¥
?o?

?,
^1ù]
e|¥Y¥
?o??bD¥?


^_,?V
üD
^?|=Y¥_1

$??¥b[|=?a1$D''L
^V?8

??B21?8,?
^?8D?8·-???

¥b°''D?Q,D|?úùD
3D¥?
=?

1/??
e?0b/Kí?Zu ú,
e??è V

?\éD?¥D?
3K¥aB??
mOT

¨¥
e?T¨b
e? ?à?
?í-?¥8

`¥9?,o??\é8`¥1á=?b?<

8`?Z¥-
?,? ?¥} ?8`¥-=??

y.,|?è\é8`¥1 ??
±?awé8`¥Q


8?a??
±?¥T¨b0[4]Lí8`¥
±?4

ù5,o?8`¥
±?,??8`¥=??y¥

??,"8`1-¥? ?} ?¥T¨b?
=Y

V [ ú?èT1
3iD
?D ?
N¥B?|¥

/
e??0,ü?D??Wé???
Llb

/YV??ò1?
?1-¥ ??é??
?,?


^21
W@?a31¥
m
0[5],??aE
?#?

? ?(PauloFreire)?/
àμ?,ü
àμ
?
@,
àμ


?
@,9ü
àμ
??¥?a0[6],?Xü?1a

C} [?¥?5Mb1

LC?
=¥\éD
3
±?

?Z¥
e??T¨,?D?ù??1?D
?¥ù?

×?b/?D?ü
^YV?
=¥4ùa ?D??,

D
31?
± Ia1?Vr7¤?
M/?a?Z? ?

¥?DZE0[7],
^?
=??ùD
3?ù5¥

34?aD2008M

3
d,
PD
3)?
±?¥?$
?iá
?1
?ù35

¥|
{b?D?¥×?
^?
=?μr1 ?¨4ù

???D
3¥
± IV?
± I8b×
j¥?
^?


M7
^V?,
^[V?1??¥?Db

(B)?
T?:E?D
3
±??Z

?T1
L=¨?·¥
^??1,?üil


¥?<?¥
^?¥ú
D?éb?Bü? ?

31
L=il
¥?,^?áü?D?F ?áaa

μùμs¥?
T AT?b.d?D4ù÷
^?


T?,?
=4ù5,D
33s,èè[|¤s?1


?@,7?
^?P4bμ?°V
ü,?
=¥ù5

80%
^o3
μ:?¥?
Mü?ís¥ù5,[8]v


ùs
??
^dù,1+1
^?
^??2?á
ì1?1[


í????aQ¥
^dù,
^?,
NYí?

??s?,Os?aaücù5?
,D
3 V[

V? ?s?,
.à V[? g7,
?i?"gs

?,?3é??f
± I,? ?
àμ
± IN′¥ù5
^

 ?n
HWb I
n?ü (
? [64%¥
HW¨??

ùsμ1¥?D?,80%
^
μ:?¥ê,f ?

M??×bD
3¥
± I?$×
j,?
="d¥μ ?μ

¥?D
34?¥?
?9M?
n,nμV¥?

D??
P?DJ?
?ù¥1?,???
??

D
3¥
±??¥T¨,MQ?E?D
3
±??

Z,1
?9z??'' ú?b

(=)μr4ù:?ZD
3
±?¥y 

?
=`_?üV? AT
^Y_"S¥o?,
L

=
D
3
± I¥V?# [)
??¥VC,ü


^×v¥"Sb1
?D
3 7?7?,á
�i

?A?VD
3A?D
I
1(=?)?D
38"D

(V?),8"
± I
,μr4ùü×?b
± I¥V

?
,
^B[1o?¥1
± I7?D¥
m
b

1.??B??M:4
U
±??T

??
=a1ù5¥ 7h?í1?1,1ù5

¥ 7h?n7??′¤,yN,`_????¥

¨:/???0a/?????0B ?¥M 7
S4ùb è

?:F??2+2=?? ?>
Tù5o
^_D
3V

r
D
3
^???s?¥èP,???uD
3

ísù5¥1??,E?D
3
± Iaísù5,??

?á?D?J?z ,9E??
=
3D
3
3?

s?¥V?b

μr4ù·ù5;5 ?=??
ü???r? [

?"¥?"S
?3¥
±??T??,''ù5??

?B??TM?,_D
34
Uá
ì?D
33?¥

?+?¥? ??T,ù5?¥?M e?"
± I¥

??,?F?i?
?μ
I
1+????usd/?

/2?F??
ey

??4
Ua??T¥nJ,


P?D? μ
·
^S
M, V[¨ ?w????

D
3ísù5
H¥
± Ié?b?Tù5
àμa?S


M, è?:F??2+2??+
????4ùo?¨


=?4
U,
Pó
^?TM?¥?
>,?4úùD
3

¨?S e
e
ì¥
±?bFX
I
1
^2+2¥s

?
??X???TM?·?D
3ís??ù5


H
?A3¥
±??T
^ík,1D
34
??
±

I¥?b
?[4ù
H??1?i=?ù5,7O

1$#D?1
Fy=?A??¨¥
± IZ
Tb

?
=31ú?Gêca??T¥?1?M,?4

3aíka1va??1",[u 7D
3¥
± I-3b

-
ja?V?4ù?¥×1?ü?üa?DM

?
μ:?b

2.ù:?D
3D??

/?
^
±?¥F??í,
±?¥??V?
^?

B"
?F?¥,
?
ì4NM1,oM|?,V7

?_B?Ka¥?)))2
?!0[1]98
z¥
±?

8,????¥aú?¥? ?b?? ?¥

?! ?1?T
bK×1¥??
??D
3iT
a


ü
e¥in¥? ??b[1]225?TD
3
?4¥

w?¥? ??
àμμ3¥
?,
1? [?w ?

? ?¥T
,???
I
1T¨byNT
D
3


±?¥V??,A?jA ??¥×1?b

¨4ù.
q?
Ma?ND
3¥VCa?D
3"

??i ?,?
^?
qE8¨¥4ù¥??,o1D
3

s?
ù5¥??s?,?
=ü-:
1?D
3

¥
± IV?4éP,°
ü=?
^?D
3μilb

7O?
=èè
^Ps?,7?
^1??4s

?¥D
3,
P?DDDs ?b?D?¥4ùD

N¥??],4ù
^1
r??¥ ?37?
^?

ND
3Xü ?3

I
1b1
???a??D
3¥


± I,á
ìA?-%`PD
3¥ís, ?¨
e
ì¥í

s ?·?
e
ì¥4??
e
ì1
&
± I¥ ?3b?


=?31á
?D
3''tís
^??¥,''t
^p

¥,o1D
34M?1?¥ís,?
=ü ?''¨D


3¥ísT1éB?4ù¥$,?D
3¥ís

é? ??ù,k?
,1pD
3t?£
ü1-

4?¥£ ,1
e
�?
? ??b£
ü?
^3


db3
d
^ùp[1á1??¥s?,
^?4?,

£
ü31D
3ùs Z4£ by1?
=31??¥


^D
3¥w ?,7?
^
e¥s?¥ \??b/F

X¨??Vr
I
1i
±?F8
1???¥?F?

?3ù??D:1
±?7?35


I
1 è0£
ü?F1
I
1
1
a?
I
1£ V

[|?F¥XE?F?
I
1???
I
1
PFa1


^B? è0?0ù¥ù51pD
3YVQ
±1

-¥
Sís ?3
da£?|?1-¥
?
±
?X,

y74ùü?1D
3D¥y b?D
3ís¥

ù?D
3μ?×? I
na×?í$Q
±a÷?


e
ì¥
Sís,??4?a[#61
&
± Iü

?aé7?úùD
3 ?31-$??V
?4?

a¥
±X,;???D
3 ?3=?,??úùD
3a

??3?¥a??T,
PD
3μ? ?s?
LC


e
ì¥ía?,11á?C-
j 7B
?
^b

D
3??
^á
�D`,?
^B?_á
ì

Q ??D?¥?
M?8b?
= V[YVD
3¥í

s1á
ì4é?D
3v7¥L
ì,??Cá
PD


3Sís¥=?
^
I
1,D
3
± I

I
1a[#
e


ì
^??
± I¥b?
=B???D
3
^8"w ?

¥,üμ??a
e
ì¥pXE,úù
e
ìb"p

4?b ?D
3 ?3 ?¥]
H,ü?μ??

?
e
ìyúé
¥ís,÷z1 ?31-¥XEb

z¥?D
^B??!?¥1o
^4ù,?

D
3¥
Sís¥ ??4ù;?\éD
3
± I,

i<?D
^B?V?b]
H9
^?CD
3
±?


T¥B?μry b
^w?D
3D?
± IaD?D

¥?DZ
Tbo9
{=?¥?D?a?D
3¥?

ZbúùD
3??
±?5
^PíD
3?Z¥ ?
b

μr4ùd"
=?D
±?-W¥ ?,
^?ZD


3
±?¥
m
b?
a?DV?
^??,μr4ùü


^?D¥
3Lboμü4ù?T
^B??DZ
T

?ù?,?T?D¥?????,?ZD
3¥
±?


á
ì??÷μ?rb?
=?D?üμr4ùT1

úùD
3?Z
±?¥B?ZE,m ??D??1

?ZD
3
±?¥/
e?0b

? IóD:

[1]?i#ˉ.á
ì8"
±?[M].{ó?,r.?:|
?

?a?
,1991:3.

[2]?ê
=SvD?a",süvD?a".C}Z''á

¨)?a
±X
@?
?֐[M].?:|
??a?
,

1980:201.

[3]
? 5+á.C}?D
?ù5[M].f?6,r.?:?a

SD?
,1982:50.

[4]Q,D.D¥ y á)))<_?[M].ò?,r1

?:?a SD?
,2004:48.

[5]?a)))??c?[M]. ó?S? SóF?9??

ó S,r1?:?a SD?
,1996:84.

[6]
?#? ? ?.$a??¥?aD[M].$y?,r1


Z:?ê
=SvD?
,2001:41.

[7]f?. [?D?D
?[M].
Z:
Z?a?
,2000:

221.

[8]
Fx.?Dh ?D[M].éì:μ2?a?
,1999:

321.

DialogueTeaching:TeachingforThinking

LVXing2yu

(DepartmentofPedagogy,EastChinaNormalUniversity,Shanghai200062,China)

Abstract:Thevalueofthinkingcannotautomaticallybecomereality;itneedseducationpsinstruction

tofullyrealizeitsfunction.However,thetraditionalteachingtakesthecontentasthecenter,leaving

thinkingaside.Itsrootliesintheconfusingofthedifferenceofthelogicofprocessandresultofthinking.

Thedialogueisawayofteachingforthinking,thecoreofwhichistheeffectiveinquiry.Theeffectivein2

quiryisthatthequestiondoesnotonlyincludethecontent,butalsoincludesomekindofspecificpsycho2

logicaloperationwhichissupposedtoguideandfacilitatethethinkingprocessofthestudentwhentheyan2

swerthequestions.Meanwhile,theeffectiveinquirymeansthatteacherasksquestionbasingonstudentps

reply.Studentisrequiredtoreconsiderhisformeranswertoexplain,confirmandsupporthisownthink2

ing.

Keywords:teachingtheory;thinking;dialogueteaching;effectiveinquiry

(3?IR??)

献花(0)
+1
(本文系孙德勤首藏)